ITC ALJ Finds Philips' Asserted Patents Invalid in Garmin Wearables Suit

Garmin Friday claimed “total victory” in Philips' lawsuit. An International Trade Commission administrative law judge's initial determination Thursday found Philips’ asserted patents were invalid and didn't cover Garmin’s popular wearable devices, Garmin said. “Garmin has repeatedly taken a stand against meritless patent lawsuits, and it is our consistent policy to fight baseless patent claims,” said Andrew Etkind, general counsel. The initial determination is subject to ITC review. Philips emailed Friday to say it's aware of ITC's initial determination. "We are studying this decision, as we determine our next steps," said a spokesperson. "Moreover, as separate to the ITC investigation, litigations related to other patents are still pending between Philips and Fitbit and Garmin," he said, saying the company will "refrain from providing further comments."