AEI Fellow Questions Clinton Telecom Agenda as 'Much to Worry About'

Presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton's telecom plan “expands handouts to political allies,” “increases government role in broadband,” “makes empty promises of less regulation” and “promises an open Internet, but delivers a closed one,” said American Enterprise Institute Center for Internet, Communication and Technology visiting fellow Mark Jamison in a blog post Thursday. Clinton released her agenda last month (see 1606280071). “Despite this enthusiasm, there is much to worry about in this agenda as it provides a blueprint for diminishing US leadership in tech,” Jamison said. “The plan will expand subsidies from the federal government to cities, regions, and states to invest in dark fiber, broadband in recreation centers and transportation centers, and free public WiFi. Of course these programs will be wrought with political favoritism and waste.” The agenda is "particularly impotent on the most pressing digital issues," glossing over "critical topics such as the role of encryption for enhancing privacy and safety, and the critical need for greater transparency into how algorithms increasingly impact everyday lives," Pennsylvania State University Palmer Chair in Telecom Sascha Meinrath wrote in the Christian Science Monitor. "We need policies to drive universal access to low-cost, high-speed connectivity, and for the two-thirds of Americans already online, we need truth-in-labeling that addresses the quarter-of-a-trillion dollars in overpayments US consumers will make by 2025. The baby steps made thus far are necessary but insufficient to address both the digital and information divides that currently exist in broadband service provision." He cited priorities such as consumers having control over their data and laying the groundwork for intelligent transportation systems. Clinton's platform "ignores nearly all of the big problems," he said, noting her one remaining Democratic challenger, Bernie Sanders, and presumptive GOP nominee Donald Trump "haven’t released anything meaningful at all."